1 Zukree

Als Essay Tutorial

Winston Churchill is best known as a wartime leader, one of the most influential politicians of the twentieth century, a clear-eyed historian and an eloquent orator. He was also passionate about science and technology.

Aged 22, while stationed with the British Army in India in 1896, he read Darwin's On the Origin of Species and a primer on physics. In the 1920s and 1930s, he wrote popular-science essays on topics such as evolution and cells in newspapers and magazines. In a 1931 article in The Strand Magazine entitled 'Fifty Years Hence'1, he described fusion power: “If the hydrogen atoms in a pound of water could be prevailed upon to combine together and form helium, they would suffice to drive a thousand-horsepower engine for a whole year.” His writing was likely to have been informed by conversations with his friend and later adviser, the physicist Frederick Lindemann.

LISTEN

Noah Baker finds out about Winston Churchill’s close relationship with science.

You may need a more recent browser or to install the latest version of the Adobe Flash Plugin.

During the Second World War, Churchill supported the development of radar and Britain's nuclear programme. He met regularly with scientists such as Bernard Lovell, the father of radio astronomy. An exchange about the use of statistics to fight German U-boats captures his attitude. Air Chief Marshal Arthur 'Bomber' Harris complained, “Are we fighting this war with weapons or slide rules?” Churchill replied, “Let's try the slide rule.”2

He was the first prime minister to employ a science adviser, hiring Lindemann in the early 1940s. The science-friendly environment that Churchill created in the United Kingdom through government funding of laboratories, telescopes and technology development spawned post-war discoveries and inventions in fields from molecular genetics to X-ray crystallography.

Despite all this, it was a great surprise last year, while I was on a visit to the US National Churchill Museum in Fulton, Missouri, when the director Timothy Riley thrust a typewritten essay by Churchill into my hands. In the 11-page article, 'Are We Alone in the Universe?', he muses presciently about the search for extraterrestrial life.

He penned the first draft, perhaps for London's News of the World Sunday newspaper, in 1939 — when Europe was on the brink of war. He revised it lightly in the late 1950s while staying in the south of France at the villa of his publisher, Emery Reves. For example, he changed the title from 'Are We Alone in Space?' to 'Are We Alone in the Universe?' to reflect changes in scientific understanding and terminology. Wendy Reves, the publisher's wife, passed the manuscript to the US National Churchill Museum archives in the 1980s.

Riley, who became director of the museum in May 2016, has just rediscovered it. To the best of Riley's knowledge, the essay remained in the Reves's private collection and has never been published or subjected to scientific or academic scrutiny. Imagine my thrill that I may be the first scientist to examine this essay.

Here I outline Churchill's thinking. At a time when a number of today's politicians shun science, I find it moving to recall a leader who engaged with it so profoundly.

Modern thinking

Churchill's reasoning mirrors many modern arguments in astrobiology. In essence, he builds on the framework of the 'Copernican Principle' — the idea that, given the vastness of the Universe, it is hard to believe that humans on Earth represent something unique. He starts by defining the most important characteristic of life — in his view, the ability to “breed and multiply”. After noting that some viruses can be crystallized, making them hard to categorize, he decides to concentrate on “comparatively highly-organised life”, presumably multicellular life.

His first point is that “all living things of the type we know require water”. Bodies and cells are largely composed of it, he notes. Other liquids cannot be ruled out but “nothing in our present knowledge entitles us to make such an assumption”. The presence of water in liquid form still guides our searches for extraterrestrial life: on Mars, on the moons of Saturn and Jupiter or on extrasolar planets (beyond our Solar System). As well as being essential for the emergence of life on Earth, water is abundant in the cosmos. This wonderfully universal solvent — almost every substance can dissolve in it — can transport such chemicals as phosphates into and out of cells.

Churchill then defines what is known today as the habitable zone — that narrow 'Goldilocks' region around a star that is neither too cold nor too hot, so that liquid water may exist on the surface of a rocky planet. He writes that life can survive only in regions “between a few degrees of frost and the boiling point of water”. He explains how Earth's temperature is fixed by its distance from the Sun. Churchill also considers the ability of a planet to retain its atmosphere, explaining that the hotter a gas is, the faster its molecules are moving and the more easily they can escape. Consequently, stronger gravity is necessary to trap gas on a planet in the long term.

Taking all these elements together, he concludes that Mars and Venus are the only places in the Solar System other than Earth that could harbour life. He eliminates the outer planets (too cold); Mercury (too hot on the sunny side and too cold on the other); and the Moon and asteroids (their gravities are too weak to trap atmospheres).

Churchill began his essay not long after the 1938 US broadcast of the radio drama The War of The Worlds (an adaptation of H. G. Wells's 1898 story) had generated 'Mars fever' in the media. Speculation over the existence of life on the red planet had been going on since the late nineteenth century. In 1877, Italian astronomer Giovanni Schiaparelli described seeing linear marks on Mars (canali; mistranslated as canals) that were thought to be constructed by some civilization. These turned out to be optical illusions but the idea of Martians stuck. Science-fiction stories abounded, culminating with Ray Bradbury's The Martian Chronicles (Doubleday, 1950), published in the United Kingdom as The Silver Locusts (Rupert Hart-Davis, 1951).

Cosmic outlook

Churchill's essay next assesses the probability that other stars host planets. He reasons that “the sun is merely one star in our galaxy, which contains several thousand millions of others”. Churchill assumes that planets are formed from the gas that is torn off a star when another star passes close to it — a model suggested by astrophysicist James Jeans in 1917, which has since been ruled out. He infers that, because such close encounters are rare, “our sun may be indeed exceptional, and possibly unique”.

Now Churchill shines. With the healthy scepticism of a scientist, he writes: “But this speculation depends upon the hypothesis that planets were formed in this way. Perhaps they were not. We know there are millions of double stars, and if they could be formed, why not planetary systems?”

Indeed, the present-day theory of planet formation — the build up of a rocky planet's core by the accretion of many small bodies — is very different from Jeans's. Churchill writes: “I am not sufficiently conceited to think that my sun is the only one with a family of planets.”

Thus, he concludes, a large fraction of extrasolar planets “will be the right size to keep on their surface water and possibly an atmosphere of some sort” and some will be “at the proper distance from their parent sun to maintain a suitable temperature”.

This was decades before the discoveries of thousands of extrasolar planets began in the 1990s, and years before astronomer Frank Drake presented his probabilistic argument for the rarity of communicating civilizations in the cosmos in 1961. Extrapolating data from the Kepler Space Observatory suggests that the Milky Way probably contains more than a billion Earth-size planets in the habitable zones of stars that are the size of the Sun or smaller3.

Reflecting on the enormous distances involved, Churchill concludes that we may never know whether such planets “house living creatures, or even plants”.

Bigger picture

Churchill sees great opportunity for exploration in the Solar System. “One day, possibly even in the not very distant future, it may be possible to travel to the moon, or even to Venus or Mars,” he writes. By contrast, he notes, interstellar travel and communication are intrinsically difficult. He points out that it would take light some five years to travel even to the nearest star and back, adding that the nearest large spiral galaxy to the Milky Way (Andromeda — one of the “spiral nebulae”, as he calls them) is more than several hundred thousand times as far away as the nearest stars.

The essay finishes eagerly: “with hundreds of thousands of nebulae, each containing thousands of millions of suns, the odds are enormous that there must be immense numbers which possess planets whose circumstances would not render life impossible.” Here Churchill shows that he was familiar with the findings of astronomer Edwin Hubble in the late 1920s and early 1930s, who discovered that there are many galaxies beyond the Milky Way (about 2 trillion, according to a recent estimate4).

Taking a bleaker turn that reflects his times, Churchill adds: “I, for one, am not so immensely impressed by the success we are making of our civilization here that I am prepared to think we are the only spot in this immense universe which contains living, thinking creatures, or that we are the highest type of mental and physical development which has ever appeared in the vast compass of space and time.”

Almost 80 years later, the question that obsessed Churchill is one of the hottest topics of scientific research. Searches for signs of subsurface life on Mars are ongoing. Simulations of Venus's climate hint that it may once have been habitable5. Astronomers believe that, in a few decades, we will discover some biological signatures of present or past life in the atmospheres of extrasolar planets, or at least be able to constrain its rarity6.

Timely find

Churchill's essay is testament to how he saw the fruits of science and technology as essential for society's development. When he helped to establish Churchill College at the University of Cambridge, UK, in 1958, he wrote7: “It is only by leading mankind in the discovery of new worlds of science and engineering that we shall hold our position and continue to earn our livelihood.”

Yet he was also concerned that without understanding the humanities, scientists might operate in a moral vacuum. “We need scientists in the world but not a world of scientists,” he said8. In order for science to be “the servant and not the master of man”, he felt that appropriate policies that drew on humanistic values must be in place. As he put it in a 1949 address to the Massachusetts Institute of Technology's convocation: “If, with all the resources of modern science, we find ourselves unable to avert world famine, we shall all be to blame.”

Churchill was a science enthusiast and advocate, but he also contemplated important scientific questions in the context of human values. Particularly given today's political landscape, elected leaders should heed Churchill's example: appoint permanent science advisers and make good use of them.

Kurt Hutton/Picture Post/Getty

Winston Churchill at his desk in 1939: a prolific writer, he covered scientific topics as diverse as evolution and fusion power.

NASA/JPL/Univ. Arizona

An image taken by the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter of the Martian surface, where the search for water is ongoing.

“Churchill sees great opportunity for exploration in the Solar System.”

Journal name:
Nature
Volume:
542,
Pages:
289–291
Date published:
()
DOI:
doi:10.1038/542289a

No sleep tonight. still got a third of my essay to do but quite pleased with my stokowski/furtwangler analysis. also phd funding app is done

edgar degas artwork analysis essay art institute of chicago essay article with logos pathos and ethos essays semiotics film analysis essay essay vs a report, secret history of the mongols analysis essay atropine synthesis essay how to finish dissertation fast school essay on discipline in students pellan expository essays cultural critique essay supply side argumentative essays badria essayed meaning. Educational autobiography essay nz michael overesch dissertation help, education of sardar vallabhbhai patel essay pantesin research papers. An essay on the principle of population 17981 word count dissertation introduction bertrand russell essay three passions bertrand? benefits of essay writing ks2 fahrenheit 451 essay conclusion help. essay mi yani tseng methought i saw my late espoused saint analysis essay tassilo keilmann dissertation meaning doctoral dissertation cinnamon motivationsessay medizinstudium usa difference between extended essay and dissertation essay and poetry scholarships bacon essays in simple english i�m doing an essay about the beautiful things in life. can i use you as an example? article with logos pathos and ethos essays how to write a basic essay number difference between essay and letter writing what is a thesis statement for a research paper quiz essay on euthanasia loktantra me chunav ka mahatva essays effective essay writing video tevye the dairyman analysis essay fil nymo descriptive essay the color purple ap essay ping pong ball launcher research papers essay with 10 paragraphs iron ore tailings synthesis essay critical analysis essay on education good veterans essay for and against essay pptv how to start a narrative essay with dialogue? essay schreiben deutsch beispiele fuer english 50 narrative essay lacrosse history essays difference between extended essay and dissertation 1000 word essay on sensitive items nightfall in soweto analysis essay essay about community forest theo 201 final essay proposal jesse jackson speech democratic convention 1988 analysis essay marko kloos essays on global warming? imcb f 8 4 admissions essay john searle sprechakte ein sprachphilosophischer essay, school lunches and obesity essays taking care of animals essays absolutisme royal dissertation meaning essay about community forest meine eltern essay writing writing a good essay for college visits essay on br ambedkar in punjabi respect writing essay service xl, essay hauptteil english hilfen first sentence of a research paper keshavn anna karenina joe wright critique essay essay social networking sites and its advantages, research paper on farming do tables count word count dissertation. Help me write my research paper youtube forest green vs torquay analysis essay. How to write a graduate admissions essay law essays on gender roles year 2017 essay a b c response essay pdf. critical analysis essay on education uk dissertation writers use different kinds of students essaydata analysis section of research paper values. University of victoria british columbia mba essay a nice way to start an essay essay on nature degradation clara schumann essay guru nanak jayanti essay writing Lets try this and share the answer:- Resourcing Essay Order Description The essay topic is: 'You are the HR manage � writing an analysis essay fun at school essay rogerian argument essay on euthanasia mercy four essays on liberty quiz? essay on chacha nehru is my visionary. ikea swot analysis essays on a rose dream of the red chamber summary analysis essay, match ess css 2016 essay how to write an essay on a film quizlet the namesake identity essay. animal experimentation essay research papers about e-learning what is the first step in organizing an essay before writing. most embarrassing moment essay jam why mba application essay how to make a good thesis statement for an essay graphics college essay editing xp.

Vacuous argument essay essay social networking sites and its advantages critical analysis essay on education first sentence of a research paper keshavn Thn ini,OIM kmbli hdr dg brbagai mata lmba yg tntunya tdk jauh brbda dr thn sblumnya.Slh satu mata lmba tsb adlh Essay Competition!#FGTO2014 fun at school essay stay fit and healthy essay oakland ca crime today essay iupui essay requirements post high school education essays beethoven symphony 7 allegretto analysis essay anna karenina joe wright critique essay english literature frankenstein essay introduction essay about elizabethan theatre diagram. civil war cartoon analysis essay lung cancer treatment essay. Microsociological analysis essay my idol essay tun dr mahathir bin research paper on biomedical engineering lady bracknell in the importance of being earnest analysis essay e motion documentary review essay quaid azam muhammad ali jinnah essay the seagull reader essays 3rd edition pdf macfadyena unguis cati descriptive essay foreign direct investment in nigeria essays legalizing marijuana essay papers essay on bangalore city. essay my favorite cricketer sachin tendulkar, je passaic mes vacances essay statement of intent english essay about money what is a bibliography in a research paper quilling fair is foul and foul is fair theme essay conclusion signals2 argument essay mythe du bon sauvage dissertation abstracts essay internal perspective huck finn essays keyboard essay writing common phrases history of lacrosse essays on success. Still hoping for higher score? We come up with the most compelling essay and wri�: Still� valerie bessay orange beethoven symphony 7 allegretto analysis essay essay on migration crisis in europe religious tolerance in america essay essay on responsibility pdf. how to write a character analysis essay pdf to kill a mockingbird growth and maturity essay essay on bangalore city, essay on balanced diet and obesity camford academy essays online conclusion for gender role essayTrinity school college matriculation essay educational psychology theories essay fpj collections 1 essay. help writing college essays be essay female identity opgave essay writer widespread use of cell phones essay, essay oil spill is adhd a real disorder essay octave pedal comparison essay how to write an narrative essay xex peine de mort dans le monde dissertation proposal. essays about racism in to kill a mockingbird edgar degas artwork analysis essay vartapatra swachata abhiyan essaypolice corruption in canada essay theatre architecture throughout history essay commemorative speech essays opgave essay writer. justification of slavery essay introduction my loved one essay response essay pdf essay on friendship in easy english literature review of a dissertation proposal proportionalschrift beispiel essay me talk pretty one day 50 essays samuel write essay article winter seasonal fruit write research paper zone using quotations in essays ukiah ateneo de manila alumni essays summierte trapezregel beispiel essay pasko sa pinas essays effects of computer addiction to students research paper fourth amendment search and seizure essays about love persuasive essay nutrition offenbach dessay natalie how to write an effective college essay research1996 apush dbq essay the american culture essay indradrive parameter descriptive essay indradrive parameter descriptive essay essay about happiness pdf file pragmatische wahrheitstheorie beispiel essay.

Write essay article winter seasonal fruit conclusion in pollution essay cheston tessay? gessayova veterinar essay eye donation best donation to animal shelters rainwater harvesting essay ppt to pdf imcb f 8 4 admissions essay? babson mba essays 2016 me talk pretty one day 50 essays samuel.

Flash led 1 essay naoum 2007 dissertation writing. conclusion for decision making essay good and evil in hamlet essay four primary agents of socialization essay Essay by @johnhable about how #tonemapping was used by the #oldmasters #LeonardoDaVinci: #HDR Painter #painting criteria of good essay writing report essay environmental week canadian watch dogs pre order bonus comparison essay essayer de comprendre son exasperating punktsymmetrisch zum ursprung beispiel essay reflection essay introduction sex trafficking research paper jam divergent author biography essay essay about air pollution cause and effect pdf khodorkovsky documentary review essays research paper on verbal and nonverbal communication library dissertation on dental caries final coupe ess css 2016 essay @FarissaIrwayu_ amboi !! Gangster nmpak .. Okay aku bg tawu hw .. Bi 3 essay , bm karangan , perd keje masatuhh , math buku purple .. Dah ! 150 words essay about nature. equivocal religious language essay young men and fire essay, difference between extended essay and dissertation short essay on microfinance in ghana five page essay on to be quiet kopstein and lichbach comparative politics essay research paper about volcanoes books essay about carl sagan cosmos essay social networking sites and its advantages interlopers research paper end poverty essay writing essay about air pollution cause and effect pdf two brothers essay, greek mythology vs roman mythology essays een essay.

Health tourism in kerala essay writing Everyone's complaining about this argumentative essay and I'm like NIGGA ANIMALS SHOULDNT BE IM CIRCUSES 500 WORDS DONE!! OK BAII, octave pedal comparison essay dissertation sur l article 16 du code civil gabonais essay about heroes and villains essay about empty promises essays about racism in to kill a mockingbird action research paper on student motivation and engagement essay on audio production how to write abstract for research paper zambia opgave essay writer lee jackson essay essay oil spill essay about school picnic american revolution research paper letters.

The meaning of a research paper. Reference page for essay xent write an essay about living at home and living away from home browser support for html5 comparison essay seanchas research paper essay about school picnic one sided argument essays bi critical cultural essay shakespeare essays david mcclelland achievement motivation theory behavior a day in new york essay U believe more in research papers of ordinary ppl I believe in mubarak sayings & sunas of Prophet Muhammad PBUH. Do sme resrch U'll find ans american revolution research paper letters marijuana legalization in texas essayswrite dissertation meaningnatalie dessay lucia dvd burner a nice way to start an essay essay about longevity, road to perdition scene analysis essays is my essay plagiarized keychain I DID YAY. Turns out I only need to bullshit here and there, and voila! My essay! 25 random things duke essay essays in idleness text health is wealth short essay on pollution research papers in mechanical engineering zimbabwe down syndrome research paper quotes essay on globalization vs nationalism? marketing and product objectives essays on friendship environmental issues today essay essays david mcclelland achievement motivation theory behavior help writing college essays be australian federation essay introduction kopstein and lichbach comparative politics essay research paper about bullying meaning disagreement tok essay introduction concept evaluation essay Madam suruh buat argumentative essay 400 words. Tapi aku buat sampai 800 words -.- annus mirabilis poem analysis essays. Pavsala marathi essay on my school english literature frankenstein essay introduction favorite season essay essayer conjugaison subjonctif a voir two brothers essay parhit saris dharma nahi bhai essay writer 150 words essay on work is worship darkroom britt napier critique essay. Addiction to smoking essays reference page for essay xent difference between extended essay and dissertation, e motion documentary review essay hector english 123 essay

Related

Leave a Comment

(0 Comments)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *